Your browser doesn't support JavaScript. Please upgrade to a modern browser or enable JavaScript in your existing browser.
Skip Navigation U.S. Department of Health and Human Services www.hhs.gov
Agency for Healthcare Research Quality www.ahrq.gov
www.ahrq.gov


Table 3. Trials of Suppressed Antiviral Therapy in Pregnant Women

Study/Year N Population Antiviral/Dose Design Length of Trial Main Outcomes/Results Quality Rating/Limitations
Watts,42 2003 162
2 groups
Adult women with recurrent genital HSV at gestational age < 36 wks Oral acyclovir 400 mg 3 times daily or placebo DB RCT 36 wks' gestation to delivery
  1. 5% of patients treated with acyclovir, and 14% of patients treated with placebo had HSV lesions at delivery (P = 0.08).
  2. 7% in the acyclovir group had positive HSV cultures and PCR, compared with 34% of placebo-treated patients (P = 0.03 and < 0.01 respectively).
  3. 4% of women in the acyclovir group delivered by cesarean, and 10% of women in the placebo group delivered by cesarean (P = 0.17).
  4. Neonatal outcomes were similar between groups.
  5. Importantly, 6% of the women in the study had persistent detection of HSV by PCR on > 20% of days, despite reporting taking 90%-100% of the acyclovir doses.
  6. The study did not examine safety of the neonate.
Good
Scott,43 2002 234
2 groups
Adult women with recurrent genital HSV at gestational age < 36 wks Oral acyclovir 400 mg 3 times daily or placebo DB RCT 36 wks' gestation to delivery
  1. Decreased frequency of clinical recurrences, 6% of treatment and 14% of placebo group had clinical HSV at delivery (P = 0.046).
  2. No women had positive HSV cultures in treatment group compared with 6% positives in placebo group (P = 0.029).
  3. No significant difference in subclinical HSV shedding in the treatment group compared with placebo group.
  4. The study did not examine safety of the neonate.
Fair/loss to followup not reported
Scott,47 2001 96 Adult women with first diagnosis of genital HSV in index pregnancy, 36 wks' gestation Oral acyclovir 400 mg 3 times daily Open-label trial with historical controls 36 wks' gestation to delivery
  1. 85% of patients adhered to treatment, 1% had clinical HSV at delivery.
  2. 4% of the cohort had clinical recurrences compared with 18%-37% of historical controls.
  3. Asymptomatic shedding occurred in 1% of women without lesions at delivery.
  4. No harms (neurological, hepatic, renal complications) were attributable to acyclovir during the neonatal period.
Poor/not randomized or blinded, groups not similar at baseline, and comparable groups not maintained
Braig,46 2001 489
3 groups
Adult women with at least 1 episode of genital HSV at gestational age < 36 wks Group 1 (n = 167) received oral acyclovir 200 mg 4 times daily; Group 2 (n = 121) received no treatment; Group 3 (n = 201), historical controls, women not given prophylaxis who had a history of genital HSV RCT with historical controls (Group 3) 36 wks' gestation to delivery
  1. The rate of cesarean delivery was 8.4% in treatment group (Group 1), 16.5% in no treatment group (Group 2), and 9.9% in historical controls (Group 3) (P < 0.001).
  2. 75% of cesarean deliveries in Group 2 and 10% of cesarean deliveries in Group 3 were done because of genital HSV.
  3. Percentage of viral shedding was 0% in Group 1, 5% in Group 2, and 0.5% in Group 3.
  4. No neonatal herpes were diagnosed during the study period and no harms for the newborn related to antiviral therapy were reported.
Poor/not randomized or blinded, not intention-to-treat, maintenance of comparable groups not reported
Brocklehurst,44 1998 63
2 groups
Adult women with recurrent genital HSV at gestational age < 36 wks Oral acyclovir 200 mg 4 times daily or placebo DB RCT 36 wks' gestation to delivery
  1. The number of clinical recurrences of genital HSV was significantly reduced in the treatment group compared with placebo (OR, 0.10; 95% CI, 0.00-0.86).
  2. This trial did not demonstrate that acyclovir use in late pregnancy reduced cesarean delivery.
  3. No HSV among neonates were reported, and no adverse complications were reported for the infants at 1-yr followup.
Poor/groups not similar at baseline, not blinded, maintenance of comparable groups not reported, loss to followup not reported
Scott,45 1996 46
2 groups
Adult women with recurrent genital HSV at gestational age < 36 wks Oral acyclovir 400 mg 3 times daily or placebo DB RCT 36 wks' gestation to delivery
  1. None of the treatment group and 35% of the placebo group had clinical evidence of recurrent genital HSV at delivery (OR, 0.04; 95% CI, 0.002-0.745; P = 0.002).
  2. Women treated with acyclovir had no cesareans for genital herpes compared with 36% of placebo group (OR, 0.04; 95% CI, 0.002-0.745; P = 0.002).
  3. No neonates had evidence of herpes infection or harms from acyclovir.
Poor/not intention-to-treat analysis, maintenance of comparable groups and loss to followup not reported

Notes: CI, confidence interval; DB, double blind; HSV, herpes simplex virus; OR, odds ratio; PCR, polymerase chain reaction; RCT, randomized controlled trials.

Return to Document

 

AHRQ Advancing Excellence in Health Care