Your browser doesn't support JavaScript. Please upgrade to a modern browser or enable JavaScript in your existing browser.
Skip Navigation U.S. Department of Health and Human Services www.hhs.gov
Agency for Healthcare Research Quality www.ahrq.gov
www.ahrq.gov


Appendix B. Excluded Studies of Instruments

Author/Year Instruments Reason for Excluding
Satz, 1978 Abbreviated Screening Battery Diagnostic, administration time not reported (8 tests in battery)
German, 1982 Alpern-Boll Developmental Profile II Diagnostic, <40 minutes to administer, unable to calculate sensitivity/specificity from data
Craig, 2000 Assessment Battery for African American English Diagnostic, 40 minutes to administer
Ward, 1984 Author created screening tool Most of the important information is not reported
Blaxley, 1983 Bankson Language Screening Test (BLST) 25 minutes to administer
Macias, 1998 Bayley Infant Neurodevelopmental Screener (BINS) Developmental pediatrician must administer
Conti-Ramsden, 2003 Children's Test of Nonword Repetition (CNRep) 15 minutes to administer
Gray, 2003 Children's Test of Nonword Repetition (CNRep) School setting, 15 minutes to administer
Macias, 1998 Clinical Adaptive Test/Clinical Linguistic Auditory Milestone Scale (CAT/CLAMS) Developmental pediatrician must administer, 15-20 minutes to administer
Plante, 1995 Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals—Preschool (CELF-P) Diagnostic, Speech-Language Pathologist required, 30-45 minutes to administer
Cost = $348
Capute, 1986 Clinical Linguistic and Auditory Milestone Scale (CLAMS) Linguistic part only, unable to calculate sensitivity/specificity from data
Leppert, 1998 Cognitive Adaptive Test/Clinical Linguistic and Auditory Milestone Scale (CAT/CLAMS) Developmental pediatrician must administer, 15-20 minutes to administer
Pittock, 2002 Cognitive Adaptive Test/Clinical Linguistic and Auditory Milestone Scale (CAT/CLAMS) Looked at ease of administration, not validity study, no data found useful
Voigt, 2003 Cognitive Adaptive Test/Clinical Linguistic and Auditory Milestone Scale (CAT/CLAMS) 15-20 minutes to administer, unable to calculate sensitivity/specificity from data
McCathren, 2000 Communication and Symbolic Behavior Scales (Communication Composite Only) Training required, 20 minutes to administer, correlation data, unable to calculate sensitivity/specificity from data
Wetherby, 2002 Communication and Symbolic Behavior Scales Developmental Profile (CSBS DP) Most of the important information is not reported
Alberts, 1995 Davis Observation Checklist for Texas (DOCT) >15 minutes to administer, 1 day DOCT administration training class to be able to administer.
Drumwright, 1973 Denver Articulation Screening Exam (DASE) Training required, 10-15 minutes to administer
Cost = $265
Bryant, 1974ly Denver Developmental Screening Test Broad screener, speech & language components not reported separate
Frankenburg, 1992 Denver Developmental Screening Test—II (DDST—II) Diagnostic, training required, no sensitivity/specificity
Stokes, 1996 Developmental Nurse Screen Not standardized or validated
Wright, 1980 Developmental Test of Visual Motor Integration Correlation data only, unable to calculate sensitivity/specificity
Drillien, 1988 Dundee Developmental Screening Program (DDSP) Diagnostic, not validation study, ages for followup were higher than preschool
Dale, 1989 Early Language Inventory 20-30 minutes to administer, correlation data
Black, 1988 Early Language Milestone Scale 1/2 of subjects were at risk for otitis media
Cost = $825
Fell, 1999 Early Vocalization Analyzer (EVA) Diagnostic, Speech-Language Pathologist must administer
Vance, 1987 Expressive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test Diagnostic, Speech-Language Pathologist must administer
Gray, 1999 Expressive one-word Picture Vocabulary Test-Revised (EOWPVT-R) Diagnostic, Speech-Language Pathologist must administer, 1-hour session for all 4 tests
Gray, 1999 Expressive Vocabulary Test (EVT) Diagnostic, Speech-Language Pathologist must administer, 1-hour session for all 4 tests
Fluharty, 1973 Fluharty Preschool Speech and Language Screening Test Correlation data only, unable to calculate sensitivity/specificity.
Stott, 2002 General Language Screen (GLS) Not standardized or validated.
Bountress, 1981 Goldman-Fristoe-Woodcock Test of Auditory Discrimination Diagnostic, Speech-Language Pathologist must administer, 20-30 minutes to administer, comparisons of tests—no gold standard, unable to calculate sensitivity/specificity from data
Bloom, 1988 Kaufman Assessment Battery for Children (K-ABC) Diagnostic, 35-85 minutes to administer, unable to calculate sensitivity/specificity from data
Paul, 1991 Language Development Survey (LDS) 30 minutes to administer, study poorly defined, unable to extract important information
Rescorla, 2002 Language Development Survey (LDS) 30 minutes to administer, compared to other screener not a gold standard
Klee, 2000 Language Development Survey (LDS) 30 minutes to administer
Eno, 1995 Lollipop Test
Cognitive Language Profile of the Early Screening Profiles
Fluharty Preschool Speech and Language Screening Test
15-20 minutes to administer, correlation data only, unable to calculate sensitivity/specificity from data
Cost = $35
Dale, 1991 MacArthur Communicative Development Inventory: Toddlers Diagnostic, 20 minutes to administer, correlation data, unable to calculate sensitivity/specificity from data
Cost = $155
Dale, 2003 MacArthur Communicative Development Inventory: UK Short Form (MCDI:UKSF) 20 min to administer, speech & language components not reported separately (unable to determine sensitivity/specificity for specific area)
Thal, 1999 MacArthur Communicative Development Inventory: Words and Gestures (CDI:WG) Most of the important information is not reported
Thal, 1999 MacArthur Communicative Development Inventory: Words and Sentences (CDI:WS) Most of the important information is not reported
Miller, 1988 Miller Assessment for Preschoolers (MAP) Diagnostic, school psychologist must administer, 30-40 minutes to administer, unable to calculate sensitivity/specificity from data
Cost = $695
Widerstrom, 1986 Miller Assessment for Preschoolers (MAP) Diagnostic, looked at discrimination factor of test
Egan, 1986 Miniature Toys Test Developmental delay study, verbal just small part, did not separate results for speech and language
Tomblin, 1999 Minnesota Child Development Inventory Correlation data only, unable to calculate sensitivity/specificity
Kopparthi, 1991 Minnesota Child Development Inventory (MCDI) Diagnostic, neonatal intensive care unit infants
Gorrell, 1981 North Carolina Psychoeducational Screening Test (PET) Diagnostic, unable to determine administration time
Ratusnik, 1975 Northwestern Syntax Screening Test 20 minutes to administer, children have comorbidities
Ratusnik, 1980 Northwestern Syntax Screening Test Speech-Language Pathologist required, 20 minutes to administer, unable to calculate sensitivity/specificity from data
Allen, 1987 Northwestern Syntax Screening Test (NSST) 20 minutes to administer
Conti-Ramsden, 2003 Noun Plural Task Diagnostic, unable to determine administration time
Stokes, 1996 Parent Questionnaire Not standardized or validated
Whitworth, 1993 Parent Questionnaire Diagnostic, unable to determine administration time, unable to calculate sensitivity/specificity
Dale, 2003 Parental concern Not standardized or validated
Conti-Ramsden, 2003 Past Tense Task (PTT) Diagnostic, unable to determine administration time
Merrell, 1997 Patterned Elicitation Syntax Test with Morphophonemic Analysis (PEST) Diagnostic, Speech-Language Pathologist required, unable to determine administration time
Vance, 1987 Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test—Revised Most of the important information is not reported
Gray, 1999 Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test (PPVT-III) Diagnostic, Speech-Language Pathologist must administer, 1-hour session for all 4 tests
Choong, 1983 Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test -Revised (PPVT-R) 10-20 minutes to administer, unable to calculate sensitivity/specificity from data
Blackman, 1990 Pediatric Examination of Educational Readiness (PEER) Diagnostic, 30 minutes to administer
Blackman, 1992 Pediatric Examination of Educational Readiness (PEER) Diagnostic, 30 minutes to administer
Palmer, 1990 Pediatric Examination of Educational Readiness (PEER) Diagnostic, 30 minutes to administer, developmental pediatricians required
Shriberg, 1986 Photo Articulation Test (PAT) 13-30 minutes to administer, not much information provided
Fagundes, 1998 Preschool Language Assessment Instrument (PLAI) 30 minutes to administer, looking at racial/cultural differences, unable to calculate sensitivity/specificity from data.
Dodge, 1980 Preschool Language Scale (PLS) Diagnostic, 25-30 minutes to administer
Stevenson, 1976 Pre-School Version of the English Picture Vocabulary Test (EPVT) Unable to calculate sensitivity/specificity from data, much of the important information is not reported
Jordan, 1973 Queensland University Aphasia and Language Test (QUALT) Diagnostic, 45-60 minutes to administer, four subtests.
Conti-Ramsden, 2003 Recall of Digits Diagnostic, Subtests from British Abilities Scale (BAS), unable to determine administration time
Rome-Flanders, 1998 Receptive Expressive Emergent Language Scales (REEL) 20 minutes to administer, correlation study comparing tests, unable to calculate sensitivity/specificity from data
Gray, 1999 Receptive one-word Picture Vocabulary Test (ROWPVT) Diagnostic, Speech-Language Pathologist must administer, 1-hour session for all 4 tests
German, 1982 Revised Denver Developmental Screening Test (R-DDST)
(Language Subtest)
Diagnostic, < 40 minutes to administer, unable to calculate sensitivity/specificity from data
Allen, 1981 Sequenced Inventory of Communication Development (SICD) Diagnostic, 30-75 minutes to administer
Cost = $395-$1050
Sturner, 1996 Speech and Language Screening Questionnaire Diagnostic, much of the important information is not reported
Fiedler, 1971 Speech Evaluation Form Not standardized or validated
Culatta, 1983 Story Retelling Not standardized or validated
Plante, 1995 Structured Photographic Expressive Language Test—Preschool (SPELT-P) Speech-Language Pathologist required, 10-15 minutes to administer
$320
Laing, 2002 Structured Screening Test Not standardized or validated
Brown, 1986 Test for Auditory Comprehension of Language (TACL) Diagnostic, 35 minutes to administer, test re-test coefficient
Wright, 1980 Test for Auditory Comprehension of Language (TACL) Diagnostic, 35 minutes to administer, correlation data only, unable to calculate sensitivity/specificity from data
Di Simoni, 1982 Token Test for Children Diagnostic, teacher administered, language comprehension score, not vocabulary, syntax or grammar, correlation data, unable to calculate sensitivity/specificity from data
Colligan, 1974 Vane Kindergarten Test (VKT) & Mecham Verbal Language Development Scale (revised) Diagnostic, technician/Specialist, 10-20 minutes to administer
Bountress, 1981 Wepman Auditory Discrimination Test Classroom, Speech-Language Pathologist must administer, comparisons of tests—no gold standard, unable to calculate sensitivity/specificity from data
Cost = $125
Coulter, 2001 WILSTAAR Screen Broad screener, speech & language components not reported separately, unable to determine administration time, unable to calculate sensitivity/specificity from data
Oakenfull, 2001 WILSTAAR Screen Speech-Language Pathologist must administer, program not just screener, unable to determine administration time

Return to Document

 

AHRQ Advancing Excellence in Health Care