Extending the Search for High-Performance Work Practices (HPWPs) in Healthcare Organizations

On September 19, 2011, Ann Scheck McAlearney made this presentation at the 2011 Annual Conference. Select to access the PowerPoint® presentation (2.2 MB). Plugin Software Help.

Slide 1

Extending the Search for High-Performance Work Practices (HPWPs) in Healthcare Organizations

Slide 2

Investigating the Role of HPWPs in Reducing and Preventing Healthcare-Associated Infections

Presenter: Ann Scheck McAlearney, Sc.D.
Associate Professor, Health Services Management and Policy, College of Public Health, The Ohio State University
Associate Professor, Pediatrics, College of Medicine, The Ohio State University

Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality
Annual Meeting, September 2011

Slide 3

Research Team Members and Collaborators

Ohio State University

• Ann Scheck McAlearney, ScD, Associate Professor, Health Services Management and Policy (HSMP).
• Julie Robbins, MHA, Doctoral Student, HSMP.

Rush University Medical Center

• Andrew Garman, PsyD, Associate Professor and Associate Chair, Dept. of Health Systems Management.

• Stephen Hines, PhD, Vice President for Research.

Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality

• Michael Harrison, PhD, Sr. Social Scientist, Organizations & Systems.

Slide 4

Research Overview

An image of 4 doctors is shown.

Slide 5

Rationale for Study

• Evidence of lower quality of care, lapses in patient safety.
• Central to delivery of high-quality patient care is presence of capable workforce.
• Growing support for link between staffing patterns and patient outcomes.

Slide 6

Findings from First Study

• Innovative HR practices, also known as high-performance work practices (HPWPs) may represent an important but underutilized strategy to improve health care systems (Garman, et. al. 2010).
• Evidence-based model for HPWP in healthcare organizations confirmed through exploratory case studies (McAlearney, et al. 2010):
  • HPWP model evident in "exemplar organizations.
  • Link to outcomes not direct, but widely accepted.

Slide 7

New Research Questions Focused on HAI Interventions

• Do HPWPs facilitate the adoption and consistent application of practices known to reduce or prevent HAIs? In what ways?
• What distinguishes healthcare organizations that are more successful in adopting evidence-based practices in HAI reduction efforts from those organizations with less effective efforts?
• What contributes to sustainability for successful HAI reduction efforts? How are HPWPs involved in efforts to sustain HAI reduction efforts?

Slide 8

Methods: Case Study Approach

Slide 9

Site Selection Criteria

• Focus on CLABSI reduction efforts in hospital ICUs:
  • To maximize variation, focus on "extreme" cases—i.e., sites with more vs. less successful efforts at reducing/sustaining reductions in CLABSI rates.
• Selection of four CUSP states from which to select case study "pairs" (from cohort 1).
• Hospital "pairs" selected based on:
  • Participation in the same state collaborative.
  • Differential outcomes in terms of CLABSI-reduction (during CUSP) (i.e., better vs. worse outcomes).
  • Similar organizational characteristics (i.e., size, teaching, urban/ rural).

Slide 10

Site Visit Process

• Nine study site visits.
• Semi-structured interviews held with key informants.
• Rigorous analysis of interview data.
• Organizational documents collected and reviewed, as appropriate (e.g., CUSP information, CLABSI protocols, QI and infection control documents, educational materials).

Slide 11

Key Informants Interviewed

• Hospital-Level Informants:
  • Infection Control (e.g., Epidemiologist, nurses).
  • Organizational leaders (e.g., CEO, COO).
  • Clinical leaders (e.g., CMO, CNO).
  • Quality improvement professionals.
• Unit-Level Informants:
  • ICU Nurses, Patient Care Coordinators, Physicians.
  • ICU Nurse Managers, Directors, Physician Directors.

Slide 12

Current Status of Project

• 4 site visits completed; 3 CUSP sites in 2 states:
  • 2 "good," 1 "less good".
• 114 key informant interviews completed:
  • Executives (n=21): CEOs, CMOs, Nursing Leaders, Quality/ Safety.
  • Managers (n=42): Nursing, Infection Control, IT, Quality/ Safety.
  • Staff (n=51): Nurses, Physicians/ Residents, Infection Control, Project Management, Purchasing.
• 5 additional site visits to be held.

Slide 13

Preliminary Findings

Slide 14

Initial Observations

• Consistency in focus on CLABSI reduction:
  • Insertion bundles/ procedures, sterile procedures, central line insertion carts.
  • Maintenance, e.g., "scrub the hub," dressing changes.
  • "Back to Basics," e.g. hand hygiene, sterile technique.
  • Identification of helpful products, e.g., end caps, Tru-D.
• Similar challenges:
  • Reductions in ICU vs. hospital-wide.
  • Data capture/reliability.
  • Information systems limitations.

Slide 15

Emerging Themes: "Success Factors"

• Benchmark is getting to zero, not just peers.
• Strong leadership involvement and support:
  • Commitment to quality improvement and CLABSI reduction at Executive/ Board level.
  • Leaders willing to "back up" efforts with changes in policy, action (e.g., MDs who won't follow protocol).
  • Support staff for "doing the right thing".
• Quality Improvement infrastructure:
  • Dedicated staff/ resources to support/facilitate improvement efforts (e.g. data, root cause analyses).

Slide 16

Emerging Themes: "Success Factors" (continued)

• Accountability for results:
  • CLABSI on scorecard, unit rates disseminated, variations explained, explored (e.g., root cause, PDSA).
  • Rewards/recognition linked to improvement.
  • Staff understand reason behind changes, success celebrated.
• Supportive organizational culture:
  • Focus on systems, not individuals.
  • Positive physician-nursing relationships.
• Multi-disciplinary focus, team effort (physicians, nurse, infection prevention, QI).

Slide 17

Emerging Themes: Challenges to Overcome

• Resource constraints: staff to support QI, additional nursing staff on units.
• Competing priorities: hard to maintain focus because so many things are "important".
• Changes in personnel: new physicians/staff can introduce variation in practice.
• Voluntary physician staff: less "control" over MDs.
• Shifting healthcare culture: collaboration, teams, system vs. individual failure.

Slide 18

Emerging Themes: Role of HPWPs

Slide 19

Emerging Themes: Role of HPWPs II

Slide 20

Emerging Themes: Role of Collaborative/ CUSP

• Considerable variation in participation/ awareness across sites (n=3 CUSP sites).
• Possible explanations:
  • Protocols for CLABSI are well-established; many hospitals efforts to prevent CLABSIs may have been underway at CUSP onset (thus affecting participation).
  • Smaller hospitals may be more likely to benefit because they have fewer resources to support quality improvement.

Slide 21

Next Steps...

Slide 22

What's Next?

• Complete site visits (by June, 2012).
• Analyze results (on-going).
• Disseminate and publish findings (2012).

Slide 23

Any Questions?

Ann Scheck McAlearney
mcalearney.1@osu.edu

Slide 24

Supplemental Information

Slide 25

Organizational Factors

Factors influencing HPWP adoption:

1. Senior leadership support.
2. HR involvement with strategic planning.
3. Capabilities of the implementers.
4. Higher number of network affiliations.
5. Financial condition / slack resources.
6. Lower union density.

Factors influencing HPWP impact & sustainability

1. Quality of the local labor market.
2. Financial condition.
3. Continued leadership support.

Slide 26

Related Publications

• McAlearney, A.S., Garman, A., Song, P, McHugh, M., Robbins, J., Harrison, M. 2011. "High-Performance Work Systems in Healthcare Management, Part 2: Qualitative Evidence from Five Case Studies." Health Care Management Review 36(3):214-226.
• Garman, A., McAlearney, A.S., Song, P., Harrison, M., McHugh, M. 2011. "High-Performance Work Systems in Healthcare Management, Part 1: Development of an Evidence-Informed Model." Health Care Management Review 36(3):201-213.
• Song, P, Robbins, J., Garman, A., McAlearney, A.S. 2011. "High-Performance Work Systems in Healthcare Management, Part 3: The Role of the Business Case for HPWP Investment in Health Care." Health Care Management Review. In press.
• McHugh M., Garman A., McAlearney A., Song P., and Harrison M. Using Workforce Practices to Drive Quality Improvement: A Guide for Hospitals. Health Research & Educational Trust, Chicago, IL. March 2010.