Advancing Excellence in America's Nursing Homes
AHRQ's 2012 Annual Conference Slide Presentation
Select to access the PowerPoint® presentation (2.3 MB).
Slide 1
Advancing Excellence in America's Nursing Homes
Cheryl Phillips, MD, AGSF
Co-Chair Advancing Excellence (AE) Campaign
SVP Public Policy and Advocacy, LeadingAge
Images: Four photographs show caregivers with elderly persons.
Slide 2
Mission
"The Collaborative assists all stakeholders of long term care supports and services to achieve the highest practicable level of physical, mental, and psychosocial well-being for all individuals receiving long term care services."
Slide 3
AE Organizations
Voting Members:
- American Academy of Nursing—Expert Panel on Aging.
- American Association for Long Term Care Nursing.
- American Association of Nurse Assessment Coordinators.
- American College of Health Care Administrators.
- American Health Care Association.
- American Health Quality Association.
- AMDA—Long Term Care.
- LeadingAge (formerly AAHSA).
- National Association of Health Care Assistants.
- National Consumer Voice for Long Term Care.
- The Commonwealth Fund.
- The Evangelical Lutheran Good Samaritan Society.
- Association of Health Facility Survey Agencies.
- Foundation of the National Association of Long Term Care Administrator Boards.
- Gerontological Advance Practice Nurses Association.
- Hartford Institute for Geriatric Nursing.
- National Association of Directors of Nursing Administration in Long Term Care.
- National Association of State Long-Term Care Ombudsman Programs.
- National Gerontological Nursing Association.
- PHI.
- Pioneer Network.
- Service Employees International Union.
Non-voting/Government Members:
- Administration on Aging.
- Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality.
- Assistant Secretary for Policy and Evaluation.
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
- Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS).
- Department of Veterans Affairs.
Slide 4
Campaign Overview
- Largest national coalition (30 organizations) of nursing home stakeholders working together to help nursing homes improve care.
- Voluntary for nursing homes (54% registered!).
- Based on measurement of meaningful goals.
- Initially a two-year campaign; incorporated in 2010 and recognized as 501(c)(3)in 2011.
- The data show that the Campaign works!
Slide 5
How the Campaign Works
Board of Directors:
- Sets Goals.
- Develops Resources.
- Provides Support.
Statewide LANES:
- Recruit nursing homes.
- Coordinates statewide activities.
- Provides support.
Nursing Home
- Registers for AE.
- Selects 3 goals, sets targets.
- Uses Campaign's Web-based resources for QA/PI.
Slide 6
What does the Campaign do?
- Provides free, practical and evidence-based Quality Assurance/Process Improvement (QAPI) resources to support quality improvement efforts in America's nursing homes.
- Commits support to those on the frontlines of nursing home care and encourages engagement of frontline staff.
- Promotes open communication and transparency among families, residents, and nursing home staff.
Slide 7
Key Elements of Advancing Excellence
- Based on meaningful issues.
- Aligned with national initiatives.
- Measurement is key.
Slide 8
Culture Change and Advancing Excellence
- Leadership.
- Person-Centered.
- Organizational Goals cross-over.
- Complement one another.
- AE focuses on the science of change (QA/PI).
- Culture change focuses on the psychology.
Must have both!!!
Slide 9
Our Working Hypothesis...
If you have good organizational workplace practices and good care planning practices, the good clinical outcomes will follow and the staff/residents/families will be happy.
Slide 10
Benefits of Participating in Advancing Excellence
- Focus on meaningful issues.
- Increased staff retention and focus.
- Better relationships in the nursing home.
- Improved satisfaction (staff/resident/family).
- Saved money (improved quality and staff retention).
- Preparation for Pay-for-Performance.
- Brings many stakeholders to the table.
- Complementary of other initiatives.
Preparation for QA/PI!
Slide 11
A Model for Change
Image: A triangle is shown divided into three levels. The top level is labeled "Outcomes." The middle layer is labeled "Care Planning, Person-centered Care." The lowest level is labeled "Organizational Workplace Practices."
Slide 12
Quality Assurance/Performance Improvement (QA/PI)
- The Affordable Care Act, Section 6102 requires CMS to strengthen QA requirements in nursing homes.
- CMS must provide technical assistance to nursing homes in order to meet new requirements..
- Law requires implementation by December 31, 2011.
- QA/PI Plans must be submitted to HHS Secretary one year later.
Slide 13
QAPI Techniques
- Identify meaningful area for improvement—things people care about!
- Define the problem.
- Determine the starting point—the baseline.
- Figure out the "root" of the problem.
- Decide what the target or improvement will be.
- Figure out what processes will impact change.
- Choose a solution that makes sense.
- Implement the solution.
- Use "Plan-Do-Study-Act Cycle" (PSDA) for improvement.
Slide 14
How does AE Help?
AE identifies meaningful topics for nursing homes to use and provides a data collection tool, examples of root cause analyses, possible interventions and other QAPI tools for improvement.
Slide 15
Using Advancing Excellence for PIs
- Nursing homes register on Web site.
- Choose 3 goals—1 clinical, 1 organizational and 1 more (may pick all 8 goals).
- Identify benchmarks.
- Set targets.
- Use Campaign resources and tools.
- Collect and monitor data using PDSA methods.
- Enter data on AE Web site regularly.
Slide 16
Current Advancing Excellence Goals
- Staff Turnover.
- Restraints.
- Pain.
- Resident Satisfaction.
- Consistent Assignment.
- Pressure Ulcers.
- Advance Care Planning.
- Staff Satisfaction.
Slide 17
"New" Advancing Excellence Goals—2012
- Hospitalizations.
- Staff Stability.
- Pressure Ulcers.
- Medications (Antipsychotic use).
- Person-Centered Care and Decisionmaking.
- Infections.
- Mobility.
- Consistent Assignment.
- Pain Management.
Slide 18
New AE Goals 2012
Image: Four cogs are shown; the largest cog contains the text "Pain, Pressure Ulcers, Antipsychotics, Hospitalizations, Mobility, Infections" and the three smaller cogs are captioned "Staff Stability," "Person-centered Care," and "Consistent Assignment." Arrows indicate which direction each cog will turn and how they interact with each other.
Slide 19
Staff Stability
- Staff work in the nursing home long enough to learn each resident's needs and preferences.
- Residents are more comfortable with caregivers who know their personal preferences and caregiving needs.
- A stable staff allows the nursing home to benefit from experience and knowledge that staff gains over time, increasing the overall competence and confidence of staff, while building strong bonds between residents and caregivers.
Slide 20
QI Process for Staff Turnover
Measure Turnover—Narrow the problem
- Determine if turnover is where you want it to be. What's the impact of high turnover? On quality? Morale? Financial?
Investigate Reasons for Turnover—Root Cause Analysis
- If turnover is high, look for reasons why. Ask the right questions: Is it low morale, no public transportation, low pay, not enough staff, poor hiring practices, etc.?
Identify and Implement Solutions to Improve Turnover
- Use interventions that address the specific problem. Use appropriate resources for solutions that are known to work.
Monitor and try different interventions if necessary.
Enter turnover data on AE Web site & monitor trend graphs.
Provide feedback to staff and others.
Slide 21
Instructions
Image: A screenshot shows a sample data entry worksheet for monitoring CNA staff turnover. Four ovals are superimposed over the screenshot and contain the following instructions:
- Step 1: Type in the Nursing Home Name and 6-digit Medicare Provider Number.
- Step 2: Enter Number of Staff and Number of Terminations in yellow columns. Monthly and annualized turnover rates will calculate automatically.
- Step 3: Print worksheet or make note of the Month, Number of Staff and Number of Terminations.
- Step 4: Click the Web link to open the NN Quality Campaign Web site to enter Month, Number of Staff and Number of Terminations.
Slide 22
Common Qs & As
Image: A screenshot shows Common Qs & As [Questions and Answers] related to the worksheet.
Slide 23
Image: A screenshot shows a sample data entry worksheet for monitoring CNA staff turnover with sample data entered.
Slide 24
Consistent Assignment
- Builds positive relationships.
- Increases resident and family satisfaction.
- Creates quicker awareness of clinical problems.
- Improves staff accountability.
- Improves communication between shifts and with other disciplines.
- Improves staff satisfaction.
- Improves Clinical and Quality Outcomes!!!
Slide 25
Using the Consistent Assignment Tool
- Use the AE Tool for Calculating Consistent to collect and analyze monthly data.
- Not as "intuitive" as the others…so be sure to view the instructional Webex video before attempting to use it.
- The tool is resident centered not staff centered.
- The tool counts the number of caregivers taking care of residents NOT the number of residents being cared for by the caregiver.
- The ONLY National Standardized way to collect this data.
Slide 26
Consistent Assignment Calculator
Image: A screenshot shows the Welcome page for the Consistent Assignment Calculator.
Slide 27
Instructions TAB
Image: A screenshot shows a sample data entry page for the Consistent Assignment Calculator. Ovals are superimposed over the screenshot and contain detailed instructions.
Slide 28
Common Qs & As TAB
Image: A screenshot shows Common Qs & As related to the Consistent Assignment Calculator.
Slide 29
Summary TAB
Image: A screenshot shows a summary of long-stay results from the sample data entered.
Slide 30
Web site: Consistent Assignment Resources
Image: A screenshot shows a list of resources related to Consistent Assignment.
Slide 31
Person-Centered Care Planning and Decision Making
- Keeps the person at the center of the care planning and decisionmaking process.
- Promotes choice, purpose and meaning in daily life.
- Achieves highest practicable level of physical, mental and psychosocial well-being
- Care plans are revised on ongoing basis to reflect a person's changing needs.
- Staff adapts to each resident's changing needs regardless of cognitive abilities.
Slide 32
Person-Centered Care Planning
- Consistency of Resident Experience with Expressed Resident Preferences.
- Participation in Care Planning.
- Based on the MDS Measures.
Slide 33
Hospitalizations
- Allows residents with acute changes in medical condition to remain in nursing home with staff who know them and can safely care for them without compromising residents' well-being or wishes.
- Avoids trauma and risks associated with hospitalization.
- Increases communication between hospital and nursing home to ensure continuity of care.
Slide 34
Medications
- Ensures that residents receive medications that are needed and appropriate for their medical condition.
- Promotes use of alternative non-pharmacological interventions may be better suited for residents who otherwise would likely be treated with antipsychotic medications.
Slide 35
Resident Mobility
- Enhances and maintains mobility (range of motion, bed mobility, transferring, walking, elimination of physical restraints, wheelchair mobility, and reduction of fall risk) as a part of daily care to helps maintain a person's function as well as physical and psychological well-being.
- Improves health and quality of life by increasing freedom of movement and activity.
Slide 36
Infections
- Prevents incidence and spread of infections to residents and staff that can cause respiratory or gastrointestinal symptoms.
- Although initial focus is on C. difficile, proposed evidence-based strategies to will help carry over to other.
Slide 37
Pain Management
- Residents have individualized, person-centered care plans to ensure appropriate care that prevents and minimizes episodes of moderate to severe pain.
- Improves a resident's ability to carry out daily activities and improves quality of life.
- Prevents depression, sleeplessness, restlessness, decline in appetite and unintentional weight loss due to pain.
Slide 38
Pressure Ulcers
- Prevents pressure ulcers or bed sores caused by staying too long in one position or by tubing or devices that press on the skin.
- Prevents pain, infection and other complications that are caused by pressure.
Slide 39
Image: A screenshot shows the Advancing Excellence in America's Nursing Homes Web site.
Slide 40
Advancing Excellence Tools
- Evidence-based, tried and tested...they work!
- Developed by experts.
- Similar to one another and user-friendly.
- Excel® worksheets.
- Simple how-to instructions.
- Calculations, trend graphs and charts built-in.
- Downloadable and ready to use.
- Complimentary materials for consumers, CNAs.
- Free.
Slide 41
Monthly Quality Tracking
Develop a HABIT of tracking key quality information MONTHLY!!!
Slide 42
Questions
For additional information please contact Cheryl Phillips, MD
cphillips@leadingage.org
