National Healthcare Quality and Disparities Report
Latest available findings on quality of and access to health care
Data
- Data Infographics
- Data Visualizations
- Data Tools
- Data Innovations
- All-Payer Claims Database
- Healthcare Cost and Utilization Project (HCUP)
- Medical Expenditure Panel Survey (MEPS)
- AHRQ Quality Indicator Tools for Data Analytics
- State Snapshots
- United States Health Information Knowledgebase (USHIK)
- Data Sources Available from AHRQ
Search All Research Studies
AHRQ Research Studies Date
Topics
- Adverse Events (1)
- Antibiotics (1)
- Antimicrobial Stewardship (1)
- Blood Clots (1)
- Cancer (5)
- Cancer: Breast Cancer (1)
- Cancer: Lung Cancer (2)
- Cardiovascular Conditions (2)
- Children/Adolescents (12)
- Chronic Conditions (1)
- COVID-19 (3)
- Critical Care (2)
- Dementia (1)
- Diabetes (2)
- (-) Diagnostic Safety and Quality (44)
- Education: Continuing Medical Education (1)
- Elderly (1)
- Electronic Health Records (EHRs) (4)
- Emergency Department (5)
- Healthcare Costs (1)
- Healthcare Delivery (1)
- Health Information Technology (HIT) (5)
- Hospital Readmissions (1)
- Hospitals (6)
- Imaging (3)
- Infectious Diseases (1)
- Inpatient Care (2)
- Intensive Care Unit (ICU) (3)
- Long-Term Care (1)
- Medical Errors (2)
- Medication (1)
- Neurological Disorders (1)
- Newborns/Infants (2)
- Nursing Homes (1)
- Patient and Family Engagement (1)
- Patient Safety (9)
- Prevention (1)
- Primary Care (1)
- Provider: Clinician (1)
- Provider: Physician (1)
- Quality Improvement (1)
- Quality Measures (1)
- Quality of Care (4)
- Racial and Ethnic Minorities (2)
- Respiratory Conditions (2)
- Risk (1)
- Screening (1)
- Sepsis (4)
- Shared Decision Making (1)
- Stroke (2)
- Surgery (1)
- Training (1)
- Urinary Tract Infection (UTI) (1)
- Women (1)
AHRQ Research Studies
Sign up: AHRQ Research Studies Email updates
Research Studies is a compilation of published research articles funded by AHRQ or authored by AHRQ researchers.
Results
1 to 25 of 44 Research Studies DisplayedSchnipper JL, Raffel KE, Keniston A
Achieving diagnostic excellence through prevention and teamwork (ADEPT) study protocol: a multicenter, prospective quality and safety program to improve diagnostic processes in medical inpatients.
This paper describes the protocol for a study that will build surveillance for hospital diagnostic errors into usual care, benchmark diagnostic performance across sites, pilot test interventions, and evaluate the program's impact on diagnostic error rates. The authors will test achieving diagnostic excellence through prevention and teamwork (ADEPT), a multicenter, real-world quality and safety program utilizing interrupted time-series techniques to evaluate outcomes. They will use a randomly sampled population of medical patients hospitalized at 16 US hospitals who died, were transferred to intensive care, or had a rapid response during the hospitalization. There will be surveillance for diagnostic errors on 10 events per month per site using a previously established two-person adjudication process. With guidance from national experts in quality and safety, study sites will report and benchmark diagnostic error rates, share lessons regarding underlying causes, and design, implement, and pilot test interventions using both Safety I and Safety II approaches aimed at patients, providers, and health systems. The primary outcome sought after will be the number of diagnostic errors per patient, using segmented multivariable regression to evaluate change in y-intercept and change in slope after initiation of the program.
AHRQ-funded; HS029366.
Citation: Schnipper JL, Raffel KE, Keniston A .
Achieving diagnostic excellence through prevention and teamwork (ADEPT) study protocol: a multicenter, prospective quality and safety program to improve diagnostic processes in medical inpatients.
J Hosp Med 2023 Dec; 18(12):1072-81. doi: 10.1002/jhm.13230..
Keywords: Diagnostic Safety and Quality, Patient Safety, Quality of Care, Hospitals, Inpatient Care
Meiselbach MK, Bai G, Anderson GF
Charges of COVID-19 diagnostic testing and antibody testing across facility types and states.
The authors discuss the practice of high charges for COVID-19 testing by some healthcare providers, with the charges for COVID-19 testing having important implications for uninsured patients, out-of-network services, and other payers without negotiating power. The purpose of this study was to examine the charges for the most commonly performed COVID-19 diagnostic test and antibody test across facility types and states. The study found that for COVID-19 diagnostic testing, the mean, median, and standard deviations of charges were $144.06, $100.00, and $162.18. The most common facility type was independent laboratories (performing 49.7% of all tests), with an average charge of $140.41, followed by hospital outpatient settings (performing 34.5% of all tests), with an average charge of $168.87. For antibody testing, the mean, median, and standard deviations of charges were $63.93, $55.00, and $48.92. Independent laboratories performed 97.2% of all tests, with an average charge of $62.30. In sum, 8.0% of diagnostic testing services and 14.0% of antibody testing claims were charged one standard deviation above the mean ($306.24 for diagnostic testing and $112.85 for antibody testing). The state average testing charges ranged between $64.98 (UT) and $505.65 (DC) for diagnostic testing, and $45.85 (NY) and $195.41 (NM) for antibody testing. AR, LA, MO, and NM had high average charges for both tests. GA, KS, MA, MD, NC, NV, and OK had low charges for both tests. No statistically significant association was found between testing charges and state-level testing rates, infection rates, or mortality rates.
AHRQ-funded; HS000029.
Citation: Meiselbach MK, Bai G, Anderson GF .
Charges of COVID-19 diagnostic testing and antibody testing across facility types and states.
J Gen Intern Med 2023 Dec; 38(16):3640-43. doi: 10.1007/s11606-020-06198-y..
Keywords: COVID-19, Diagnostic Safety and Quality, Healthcare Costs
Michelson KA, Bachur RG, Rangel SJ
Emergency department volume and delayed diagnosis of pediatric appendicitis: a retrospective cohort study.
The objective of this study was to assess the association of emergency department (ED) volume of children and delayed appendicitis diagnoses and to compare complication rates by delayed diagnosis occurrence. HCUP data from eight states were studied on children under the age of 18 with appendicitis in all EDs. The results indicated that higher ED volumes were associated with lower risk of delayed diagnosis of pediatric appendicitis; delay was associated with complications.
AHRQ-funded; HS026503.
Citation: Michelson KA, Bachur RG, Rangel SJ .
Emergency department volume and delayed diagnosis of pediatric appendicitis: a retrospective cohort study.
Ann Surg 2023 Dec 1; 278(6):833-38. doi: 10.1097/sla.0000000000005972..
Keywords: Children/Adolescents, Emergency Department, Diagnostic Safety and Quality
Hasegawa S, Livorsi DJ, Perencevich EN S, Livorsi DJ, Perencevich EN
Diagnostic accuracy of hospital antibiograms in predicting the risk of antimicrobial resistance in enterobacteriaceae isolates: a nationwide multicenter evaluation at the Veterans Health Administration.
This study examined the effectiveness of an antibiogram to predict antimicrobial resistance (AMR) at the patient-level for Escherichia coli and Klebsiella spp. The authors retrospectively generated hospital antibiograms for the nationwide Veterans Health Administration (VHA) facilities from 2000 to 2019 using all clinical culture specimens positive for E. coli and Klebsiella spp., then assessed the diagnostic accuracy of an antibiogram to predict resistance for isolates in the following calendar year using logistic regression models and predefined 5-step interpretation thresholds. At 127 VHA facilities, the discrimination abilities of hospital-level antibiograms in predicting individual patient AMR were mostly poor, with the areas under the receiver operating curve at 0.686 and 0.715 for ceftriaxone, 0.637 and 0.675 for fluoroquinolones, and 0.576 and 0.624 for trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole, respectively.
AHRQ-funded; HS027472.
Citation: Hasegawa S, Livorsi DJ, Perencevich EN S, Livorsi DJ, Perencevich EN .
Diagnostic accuracy of hospital antibiograms in predicting the risk of antimicrobial resistance in enterobacteriaceae isolates: a nationwide multicenter evaluation at the Veterans Health Administration.
Clin Infect Dis 2023 Nov 30; 77(11):1492-500. doi: 10.1093/cid/ciad467..
Keywords: Diagnostic Safety and Quality, Hospitals
Cifra CL, Custer JW, Smith CM
Prevalence and characteristics of diagnostic error in pediatric critical care: a multicenter study.
This study’s objective was to determine the prevalence and characteristics of diagnostic errors and identify factors associated with error in patients admitted to the PICU. This multicenter cohort study used structured medical record review by trained clinicians using the Revised Safer Dx instrument to identify diagnostic error (defined as missed opportunities in diagnosis). The cohort included 882 randomly selected patients 0-18 years old who were nonelectively admitted to participating PICUs. Of these admissions, 13 (1.5%) had a diagnostic error up to 7 days after PICU admission, with infections (46%) and respiratory conditions (23%) being the most missed diagnoses. One diagnostic error caused a prolonged hospital stay. Common missed diagnostic opportunities included failure to consider the diagnosis despite a suggestive history and failure to broaden diagnostic testing, both at 69%. Unadjusted analysis identified more diagnostic errors in patients with atypical presentations (23.1% vs 3.6%), neurologic chief complaints (46.2% vs 18.8%), admitting intensivists greater than or equal to 45 years old (92.3% vs 65.1%), admitting intensivists with more service weeks/year (mean 12.8 vs 10.9 weeks), and diagnostic uncertainty on admission (77% vs 25.1%). Generalized linear mixed models determined that atypical presentation (odds ratio [OR] 4.58) and diagnostic uncertainty on admission (OR 9.67) were significantly associated with diagnostic error.
AHRQ-funded; HS026965.
Citation: Cifra CL, Custer JW, Smith CM .
Prevalence and characteristics of diagnostic error in pediatric critical care: a multicenter study.
Crit Care Med 2023 Nov; 51(11):1492-501. doi: 10.1097/ccm.0000000000005942..
Keywords: Children/Adolescents, Diagnostic Safety and Quality, Critical Care, Intensive Care Unit (ICU), Medical Errors, Patient Safety
Baghdadi JD, O'Hara LM, Johnson JK
Diagnostic stewardship to support optimal use of multiplex molecular respiratory panels: a survey from the Society for Healthcare Epidemiology of America Research Network.
This study’s objective was to explore current and future approaches to diagnostic stewardship of multiplex polymerase chain reaction (PCR) respiratory panels. The authors conducted a survey of the Society for Healthcare Epidemiology of America Research Network, with 41 sites completing the survey (response rate, 50%). Results of the survey were that multiplex PCR respiratory panels were perceived as supporting accurate diagnoses at 35 sites (85%), supporting more efficient patient care at 33 sites (80%), and improving patient outcomes at 23 sites (56%). Additionally, 24 sites (58%) had implemented diagnostic stewardship, with a median of 3 interventions (interquartile range, 1-4) per site. The interventions most frequently reported as effective were structured order sets to guide test ordering (4 sites), restrictions on test ordering based on clinician or patient characteristics (3 sites), and structured communication of results (2 sites), with 3 sites reporting that education was “helpful” but with limitations.
AHRQ-funded; HS028854.
Citation: Baghdadi JD, O'Hara LM, Johnson JK .
Diagnostic stewardship to support optimal use of multiplex molecular respiratory panels: a survey from the Society for Healthcare Epidemiology of America Research Network.
Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol 2023 Nov; 44(11):1823-28. doi: 10.1017/ice.2023.72..
Keywords: Diagnostic Safety and Quality, Respiratory Conditions
Michelson KA, Bachur RG, Cruz AT
Multicenter evaluation of a method to identify delayed diagnosis of diabetic ketoacidosis and sepsis in administrative data.
The objectives of this study were to derive a method of automated identification of delayed diagnosis of two serious pediatric conditions in the emergency department (ED). Subjects were patients under the age of 21 who had two EDs encounters within 7 days, the second resulting in a diagnosis of new-onset diabetic ketoacidosis (DKA) or sepsis. The results showed that delayed diagnosis was present in 89 % of DKA patients seen twice within 7 days. 17 % of sepsis patients were deemed to have delayed diagnosis; the authors noted that many children with sepsis delayed diagnosis may be identified using the proposed approach with low specificity, indicating a need for manual case review. The fewer days between ED encounters was the most important characteristic associated with delayed diagnosis.
AHRQ-funded; HS026503.
Citation: Michelson KA, Bachur RG, Cruz AT .
Multicenter evaluation of a method to identify delayed diagnosis of diabetic ketoacidosis and sepsis in administrative data.
Diagnosis 2023 Nov; 10(4):383-89. doi: 10.1515/dx-2023-0019..
Keywords: Diabetes, Diagnostic Safety and Quality, Sepsis
Woods-Hill CZ, Koontz DW, Colantuoni EA
Sustainability of the Bright STAR diagnostic stewardship program to reduce blood culture rates among critically ill children.
From 2017 to2020, 14 pediatric intensive care units (PICUs) participated in the Bright STAR (Testing Stewardship for Antibiotic Reduction) QI collaborative to reduce unnecessary blood cultures for PICU patients. The collaborative project found that 4 sites demonstrated a 33% decrease in blood culture rates and a 13% decrease in broad spectrum antibiotic use. The purpose of this current study was to assess whether sites sustained reduced blood culture rates after completion of the formal project. The study found that all sites had lower blood culture rates during the sustainability period when compared with the pre-implementation period. The blood culture rate increased 8% during the sustainability period compared with the postimplementation period but was 27% lower than during the pre-implementation period.
AHRQ-funded; HS025642.
Citation: Woods-Hill CZ, Koontz DW, Colantuoni EA .
Sustainability of the Bright STAR diagnostic stewardship program to reduce blood culture rates among critically ill children.
JAMA Pediatr 2023 Nov; 177(11):1234-37. doi: 10.1001/jamapediatrics.2023.3229..
Keywords: Children/Adolescents, Critical Care, Quality Improvement, Diagnostic Safety and Quality, Quality of Care
Georgette N, Michelson K, Monuteaux M
A temperature- and age-adjusted shock index for emergency department identification of pediatric sepsis.
The objective of this retrospective cohort study was to derive a temperature- and age-adjusted mean shock index (TAMSI) for early identification of sepsis and septic shock in children with suspected infection. Researchers analyzed data on children who presented with suspected infection to a single emergency department over a 10-year period. Test characteristics for the TAMSI cutoffs were compared with those for the Pediatric Advanced Life Support (PALS) tachycardia or systolic hypotension cutoffs. The results showed that TAMSI achieved a similar negative likelihood ratio and improved positive likelihood ratio compared with PALS vital sign cutoffs for the prediction of septic shock, but did not improve on PALS for sepsis prediction among children with suspected infection.
AHRQ-funded; HS026503.
Citation: Georgette N, Michelson K, Monuteaux M .
A temperature- and age-adjusted shock index for emergency department identification of pediatric sepsis.
Ann Emerg Med 2023 Oct; 82(4):494-502. doi: 10.1016/j.annemergmed.2023.03.026..
Keywords: Children/Adolescents, Emergency Department, Sepsis, Diagnostic Safety and Quality
Gupta AB, Greene MT, Fowler KE
Associations between hospitalist shift busyness, diagnostic confidence, and resource utilization: a pilot study.
Hospitalists are frequently attending to multiple tasks when overseeing patient care, and patients are at risk for diagnostic errors. The purpose of this single-center, prospective, pilot observational study was to measure hospitalist workload and examine its influences on diagnostic performance in a real-world clinical setting. The researchers had hospitalists admitting new patients to the hospital complete an abbreviated Mindful Attention Awareness Tool and a survey on diagnostic confidence upon shift completion. Complete data were available for 37 unique hospitalists who admitted 160 unique patients. The study found that increases in admissions and pages were related with higher odds of hospitalists reporting it was "difficult to focus on what is happening in the present." Increased pages was associated with a decrease in the number of differential diagnoses listed.
AHRQ-funded; HS024385; HS025891.
Citation: Gupta AB, Greene MT, Fowler KE .
Associations between hospitalist shift busyness, diagnostic confidence, and resource utilization: a pilot study.
J Patient Saf 2023 Oct 1; 19(7):447-52. doi: 10.1097/pts.0000000000001157..
Keywords: Hospitals, Diagnostic Safety and Quality, Patient Safety
Bonner SN, Lagisetty K, Reddy RM
Clinical implications of removing race-corrected pulmonary function tests for African American patients requiring surgery for lung cancer.
This study’s objective was to identify how many hospitals providing lung cancer surgery use race correction in pulmonary function tests (PFTs), examine the association of race correction with predicted lung function, and test the effect of decorrection on surgeons' treatment recommendations. Percent predicted preoperative and postoperative forced expiratory volume in 1 second (FEV1) was calculated for African American patients who underwent lung cancer resection between January 1, 2015, and September 31, 2022, using race-corrected and race-neutral equations for hospitals performing race correction. Randomization of US cardiothoracic surgeons was conducted to receive 1 clinical vignette that differed by the use of Global Lung Function Initiative equations for (1) African American patients (percent predicted postoperative FEV1, 49%), (2) other race or multiracial patients (percent predicted postoperative FEV1, 45%), and (3) race-neutral patients (percent predicted postoperative FEV1, 42%). A total of 515 African American patients (308 [59.8%] female; mean age, 66.2 years) were included in the study. Among these patients, the percent predicted preoperative FEV1 and postoperative FEV1 would have decreased by 9.2% and 7.6%, respectively, if race-neutral equations had been used. A total of 225 surgeons (194 male [87.8%]; mean time in practice, 19.4 years) were successfully randomized and completed the vignette items regarding risk perception and treatment outcomes (76% completion rate). Surgeons randomized to the vignette with African American race-corrected PFTs were more likely to recommend lobectomy (79.2%) compared with surgeons randomized to the other race or multiracial-corrected (61.7%) or race-neutral PFTs (52.8%).
AHRQ-funded; HS028038.
Citation: Bonner SN, Lagisetty K, Reddy RM .
Clinical implications of removing race-corrected pulmonary function tests for African American patients requiring surgery for lung cancer.
JAMA Surg 2023 Oct; 158(10):1061-68. doi: 10.1001/jamasurg.2023.3239..
Keywords: Racial and Ethnic Minorities, Cancer: Lung Cancer, Cancer, Surgery, Diagnostic Safety and Quality
Bourgeois FC, Hart NJ, Dong Z
Partnering with patients and families to improve diagnostic safety through the OurDX tool: effects of race, ethnicity, and language preference.
This study’s objective was to explore differences in race, ethnicity, and language preference associated with patient and family contributions and concerns using an electronic previsit tool designed to engage pediatric patients and their families in the diagnostic process (DxP). This cross-sectional study included 5,731 patients and families presenting to three subspecialty clinics at an urban pediatric hospital May to December 2021 who completed a previsit tool, which was codeveloped and tested with patients and families. Patients/families were invited to share visit priorities, recent histories, and potential diagnostic concerns prior to each visit. The authors conducted chart review on a random subset of visits to review concerns and determine whether patient/family contributions were included in the visit note. Compared with patients self-identifying as White, those self-identifying as Black (odds ratio [OR]: 1.70) or "other" race (OR: 1.48) were more likely to report a diagnostic concern. Participants who preferred a language other than English were more likely to report a diagnostic concern than English-preferring patients (OR: 2.53). No significant differences were found in physician-verified diagnostic concerns or in integration of patient contributions into the note based on race, ethnicity, or language preference.
AHRQ-funded; HS027367.
Citation: Bourgeois FC, Hart NJ, Dong Z .
Partnering with patients and families to improve diagnostic safety through the OurDX tool: effects of race, ethnicity, and language preference.
Appl Clin Inform 2023 Oct; 14(5):903-12. doi: 10.1055/s-0043-1776055..
Keywords: Diagnostic Safety and Quality, Patient Safety, Racial and Ethnic Minorities
Evans NJ, Arakkal AT, Cavanaugh JE
The incidence, duration, risk factors, and age-based variation of missed opportunities to diagnose pertussis: a population-based cohort study.
This study’s objective was to estimate the incidence, duration and risk factors for diagnostic delays associated with pertussis. The authors used longitudinal retrospective insurance claims from the Marketscan Commercial Claims and Encounters, Medicare Supplemental (2001-2020), and Multi-State Medicaid (2014-2018) databases. They estimated the number of visits with pertussis-related symptoms before diagnosis beyond that expected in the absence of diagnostic delays, including the number of visits representing a delay, the number of missed diagnostic opportunities per patient, and the duration of delays. They identified 20,828 patients meeting inclusion criteria. On average, delay duration was 12 days, and patients had almost 2 missed opportunities prior to diagnosis. The duration of delays increased considerably with age from an average of 5.6 days for patients aged less than 2 years to 13.8 days for patients aged ≥18 years. Factors associated with increased risk of delays included recent prescriptions for antibiotics not effective against pertussis, emergency department visits, and telehealth visits.
AHRQ-funded; HS027375.
Citation: Evans NJ, Arakkal AT, Cavanaugh JE .
The incidence, duration, risk factors, and age-based variation of missed opportunities to diagnose pertussis: a population-based cohort study.
Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol 2023 Oct; 44(10):1629-36. doi: 10.1017/ice.2023.31..
Keywords: Respiratory Conditions, Risk, Diagnostic Safety and Quality
Zhu Y, Wang Z, Newman-Toker D
Misdiagnosis-related harm quantification through mixture models and harm measures.
Investigating and monitoring misdiagnosis-related harm utilizing the traditional chart review process is labor intensive, potentially unstable, and not conducive to scaling. Researchers propose to leverage the association between symptoms and diseases based on electronic health records or claim data. Specifically, the increased risk of disease after a false-negative diagnosis can be utilized as an indicator of potential harm. The researcher report that the problem with off-the-shelf statistical methods to assess these dynamics is that they do not fully accommodate the data structure of a well-hypothesized risk pattern and thus fail to sufficiently address the unique challenges. The purpose of this study was to explore a mixture regression model and its associated goodness-of-fit testing to address the existing gaps seen in usual statistical analysis methods. The researchers additionally proposed harm measures and profiling analysis procedures to quantify, assess, and compare misdiagnosis-related harm across institutes with potentially differing patient population compositions. Simulation studies were utilized to study the performance of the proposed methods. Researchers then applied and demonstrated the methods through data analyses on stroke occurrence data from the Taiwan Longitudinal Health Insurance Database. From those analyses risk factors for being harmed due to misdiagnosis were assessed, which revealed insights for health care quality research. Finally, researchers compared general and special care hospitals in Taiwan and observed better diagnostic performance in special care hospitals utilizing a variety of new assessment measures.
AHRQ-funded; HS027614.
Citation: Zhu Y, Wang Z, Newman-Toker D .
Misdiagnosis-related harm quantification through mixture models and harm measures.
Biometrics 2023 Sep; 79(3):2633-48. doi: 10.1111/biom.13759..
Keywords: Diagnostic Safety and Quality, Patient Safety, Hospitals
Murphy DR, Zimolzak AJ, Upadhyay DK
Developing electronic clinical quality measures to assess the cancer diagnostic process.
Electronic clinical quality measures (eCQMs) to evaluate quality of cancer diagnosis could facilitate quantification and improvement of diagnostic performance. The purpose of this study was to developed 2 eCQMs to evaluate diagnostic assessment of red-flag clinical findings for colorectal cancer (CRC) and lung cancer. At each site the researchers assessed 100 positive and 20 negative randomly chosen records for each eCQM at each site to validate accuracy and categorized missed opportunities associated with system, provider, or patient factors. The researchers applied the CRC eCQM at both sites, while the lung cancer eCQM was only applied at the VA due to an absence of structured data indicating level of cancer suspicion on most chest imaging results at Geisinger. The study found that for the CRC eCQM, the appropriate follow-up took place in 26, 746 out of 74, 314 patients (36.0%) in the VA after removing clinical exclusions and in 1,009 out of 2,461 patients (41.1%) at Geisinger. The appropriate assessment for lung cancer in the VA took place in 25, 166 out of 40, 924 patients (61.5). Provider factors were cited by reviewers the primary source of missed opportunities at both sites.
AHRQ-funded; HS022087.
Citation: Murphy DR, Zimolzak AJ, Upadhyay DK .
Developing electronic clinical quality measures to assess the cancer diagnostic process.
J Am Med Inform Assoc 2023 Aug 18; 30(9):1526-31. doi: 10.1093/jamia/ocad089..
Keywords: Cancer: Lung Cancer, Cancer, Quality Measures, Diagnostic Safety and Quality, Quality of Care
Tarnutzer AA, Gold D, Wang Z
Impact of clinician training background and stroke location on bedside diagnostic test accuracy in the acute vestibular syndrome - a meta-analysis.
Researchers conducted a systematic review to assess the accuracy of bedside diagnosis of acute dizziness/vertigo to differentiate peripheral vestibular from central neurologic causes. Their review indicated that the Head Impulse, Nystagmus, Test of Skew (HINTS) examination by trained clinicians can differentiate peripheral from central causes and show higher diagnostic accuracy for stroke in the first 24-48 hours than MRI diffusion-weighted imaging. They concluded that these techniques should be disseminated to clinicians evaluating dizziness/vertigo.
AHRQ-funded; HS029350.
Citation: Tarnutzer AA, Gold D, Wang Z .
Impact of clinician training background and stroke location on bedside diagnostic test accuracy in the acute vestibular syndrome - a meta-analysis.
Ann Neurol 2023 Aug; 94(2):295-308. doi: 10.1002/ana.26661..
Keywords: Diagnostic Safety and Quality, Training, Education: Continuing Medical Education, Provider: Clinician, Stroke, Cardiovascular Conditions
Liberman AL, Wang Z, Zhu Y
Optimizing measurement of misdiagnosis-related harms using Symptom-Disease Pair Analysis of Diagnostic Error (SPADE): comparison groups to maximize SPADE validity.
The purpose of this paper was to clarify features of the Symptom-Disease Pair Analysis of Diagnostic Error (SPADE) approach to accurately measure diagnostic errors to assure that researchers utilize this method to yield valid results, as well as improve the validity of SPADE and related approaches to quantify diagnostic error in medicine. The researchers describe four types of comparators (intra-group and inter-group), detailing the reason for selecting one over the other and conclusions that can be drawn from these comparative analyses.
AHRQ-funded; HS027614.
Citation: Liberman AL, Wang Z, Zhu Y .
Optimizing measurement of misdiagnosis-related harms using Symptom-Disease Pair Analysis of Diagnostic Error (SPADE): comparison groups to maximize SPADE validity.
Diagnosis 2023 Aug 1; 10(3):225-34. doi: 10.1515/dx-2022-0130..
Keywords: Diagnostic Safety and Quality, Medical Errors, Adverse Events, Electronic Health Records (EHRs), Health Information Technology (HIT), Patient Safety
Young AL, Monuteaux MC, Cooney TM
Predictors of delayed diagnosis of pediatric CNS tumors in the emergency department.
Delays in the diagnosis of central nervous system (CNS) tumors in children may lead to adverse outcomes and undue burdens on families. The purpose of this study was to examine factors related with delayed emergency department (ED) diagnosis to identify approaches to reduce delays. Researchers included 2828 children, 76% were controls, 24% were cases). Among cases, 68% had 1 preceding ED visit, 21% had 2, and 11% had 3 or more. The study found significant predictors of delayed diagnosis included presence of a complex chronic condition, rural hospital location, nonteaching hospital status, age younger than 5 years, public insurance, and black race.
AHRQ-funded; HS026503.
Citation: Young AL, Monuteaux MC, Cooney TM .
Predictors of delayed diagnosis of pediatric CNS tumors in the emergency department.
Pediatr Emerg Care 2023 Aug; 39(8):617-22. doi: 10.1097/pec.0000000000002943..
Keywords: Children/Adolescents, Diagnostic Safety and Quality, Cancer, Emergency Department
Rao G, Ufholz K, Saroufim P
Recognition, diagnostic practices, and cancer outcomes among patients with unintentional weight loss (UWL) in primary care.
The objective of this study was to identify the incidence, rate of physician recognition, diagnostic practices, and cancer outcomes for unintentional weight loss. Researchers completed a secondary analysis of structured and unstructured EHR data collected from adult, established primary care patients with a minimum of two weight measurements in 2020 and in 2021. The results indicated that unintentional weight loss is poorly recognized across a diverse range of patients. The researchers concluded that lack of research-informed guidance may explain low rates of recognition and variability in diagnostic practices.
AHRQ-funded; HS029358.
Citation: Rao G, Ufholz K, Saroufim P .
Recognition, diagnostic practices, and cancer outcomes among patients with unintentional weight loss (UWL) in primary care.
Diagnosis 2023 Aug 1; 10(3):267-74. doi: 10.1515/dx-2023-0002..
Keywords: Cancer, Primary Care, Diagnostic Safety and Quality, Provider: Physician
Pinevich Y, Barwise AK, Austin JM
Time to diagnostic certainty for saddle pulmonary embolism in hospitalized patients.
The purpose of this retrospective observational study was to explore the concept of the time to diagnostic certainty, defined as the interval between first patient presentation and confirmed pulmonary embolism (PE) diagnosis with computed tomography pulmonary angiogram (CT PA). Participants were randomly selected adult patients admitted to academic medical centers and associated community-based hospitals in one health system with a diagnosis of acute saddle PE. Time to diagnostic certainty ranged from 1.5 to 310 hours; the median time to treatment was 3.5 hours.
AHRQ-funded; HS026609.
Citation: Pinevich Y, Barwise AK, Austin JM .
Time to diagnostic certainty for saddle pulmonary embolism in hospitalized patients.
Biomol Biomed 2023 Jul 3; 23(4):671-79. doi: 10.17305/bb.2022.8393..
Keywords: Diagnostic Safety and Quality, Blood Clots
Michelson KA, McGarghan FLE, Waltzman ML
Community validation of an approach to detect delayed diagnosis of appendicitis in big databases.
This study’s goal was to further validate a trigger tool that has been used in community emergency departments (EDs) to detect delayed diagnosis of pediatric appendicitis. The authors studied patients <21 years old diagnosed with appendicitis from 2008 to 2019 in 8 eastern Massachusetts EDs. Eligible patients had 2 ED encounters within 7 days, the second time ending with an appendicitis diagnosis. Trained reviewers evaluated medical records that showed delayed diagnosis. The previously validated trigger tool was applied to participants’ electronic medical record data, with the tool assigning a probability of delayed diagnosis for each patient. Four confidence thresholds were determined, and the area under the receiver operating curve was calculated. The authors analyzed 68 children with 2 encounters leading to a diagnosis of appendicitis (i.e., possible delay). A delayed diagnosis prediction was assigned to patients at 4 thresholds of confidence (>0%, >50%, >75%, and >90% confident), the positive predictive values were respectively 74%, 89%, 92%, and 89%; the negative predictive values were respectively 100%, 57%, 50%, and 33%. The area under the receiver operating curve was 0.837.
AHRQ-funded; HS026503.
Citation: Michelson KA, McGarghan FLE, Waltzman ML .
Community validation of an approach to detect delayed diagnosis of appendicitis in big databases.
Hosp Pediatr 2023 Jul; 13(7):e170-e74. doi: 10.1542/hpeds.2023-007204..
Keywords: Children/Adolescents, Diagnostic Safety and Quality
Garber A, Garabedian P, Wu L
Developing, pilot testing, and refining requirements for 3 EHR-integrated interventions to improve diagnostic safety in acute care: a user-centered approach.
This study’s objective was to describe a user-centered approach to develop, pilot test, and refine requirements for 3 electronic health record (EHR)-integrated interventions that target key diagnostic process failures in hospitalized patients. The interventions to be developed were a Diagnostic Safety Column (DSC) within an EHR-integrated dashboard to identify at-risk patients; a Diagnostic Time-Out (DTO) for clinicians to reassess the working diagnosis; and a Patient Diagnosis Questionnaire (PDQ) to gather patient concerns about the diagnostic process. After initial refinement from an analysis, final requirements were created for 10 test cases predicted by the DSC, 18 clinician DTO participants, and 39 PDQ responses including the following: DSC configurable parameters (variables, weights) to adjust baseline risk estimates in real-time based on new clinical data collected during hospitalization; more concise DTO wording and flexibility for clinicians to conduct the DTO with or without the patient present; and integration of PDQ responses into the DSC to ensure closed-looped communication with clinicians. An analysis of focus groups confirmed that tight integration of the interventions with the EHR would be necessary to prompt clinicians to reconsider the working diagnosis in cases with elevated diagnostic error (DE) risk or uncertainty. Potential implementation barriers identified included alert fatigue and distrust of the risk algorithm (DSC); time constraints, redundancies, and concerns about disclosing uncertainty to patients (DTO); and patient disagreement with the care team's diagnosis (PDQ).
AHRQ-funded; HS026613.
Citation: Garber A, Garabedian P, Wu L .
Developing, pilot testing, and refining requirements for 3 EHR-integrated interventions to improve diagnostic safety in acute care: a user-centered approach.
JAMIA Open 2023 Jul; 6(2):ooad031. doi: 10.1093/jamiaopen/ooad031..
Keywords: Electronic Health Records (EHRs), Health Information Technology (HIT), Diagnostic Safety and Quality, Patient Safety
Bradford A, Goeschel C, Shofer M
AHRQ Author: Shofer M
Five new ways to advance diagnostic safety in your clinical practice.
This AHRQ-authored article describes new resources that clinicians can use to advance diagnostic safety and prevent errors. The new AHRQ-funded resources include Calibrate Dx, Measure Dx, Safer Dx Checklist, TeamSTEPPS for Diagnostic Improvements, and the Toolkit for Engaging Patients to Improve Diagnostic Safety. A table is provided which describes the resource, gives an example or strategy or practice change, and describes the audience for the resource. Recommendations are also given to help clinicians reduce barriers to diagnostic safety including: 1) Start small and focused; 2) Align with other high-priority initiatives; 3) Start with the resources you have; and 4) Consider how diagnostic safety work can enhance missions other than clinical care.
AHRQ-authored.
Citation: Bradford A, Goeschel C, Shofer M .
Five new ways to advance diagnostic safety in your clinical practice.
Am Fam Physician 2023 Jul; 108(1):14-16..
Keywords: Diagnostic Safety and Quality, Patient Safety
Congdon M, Rauch B, Carroll B
Opportunities for diagnostic improvement among pediatric hospital readmissions.
The purpose of this retrospective cohort study was to: 1) identify and describe diagnostic errors, termed "missed opportunities for improving diagnosis" (MOIDs) in general pediatric patients who experienced hospital readmission, 2) outline improvement opportunities, and 3) explore factors associated with increased risk of MOID. The researchers included unplanned readmissions within 15 days of discharge from a freestanding children's hospital between October 2018 and September 2020. Health records were reviewed and discussed by practicing inpatient physicians to identify MOIDs using SaferDx, an established instrument. MOIDs were evaluated using a diagnostic-specific tool to identify improvement opportunities within the diagnostic process. The study found that MOIDs were identified in 6.3% of 348 readmissions. Opportunities for improvement included: delay in considering the correct diagnosis (50%) and failure to order needed test (45%). Patients with MOIDs were older than patients without MOIDs but similar in gender, primary language, race, ethnicity, and insurance type. The researchers did not identify conditions related with higher risk of MOID. Lower respiratory tract infections accounted for 26% of admission diagnoses but only 1 (4.5%) case of MOID.
AHRQ-funded; HS028682.
Citation: Congdon M, Rauch B, Carroll B .
Opportunities for diagnostic improvement among pediatric hospital readmissions.
Hosp Pediatr 2023 Jul; 13(7):563-71. doi: 10.1542/hpeds.2023-007157..
Keywords: Children/Adolescents, Diagnostic Safety and Quality, Hospitals, Hospital Readmissions
Michelson KA, Bachur RG, Grubenhoff JA
Outcomes of missed diagnosis of pediatric appendicitis, new-onset diabetic ketoacidosis, and sepsis in five pediatric hospitals.
This study’s objective was to determine 90-day complication rates and hospital utilization after a missed diagnosis of pediatric appendicitis, new-onset diabetic ketoacidosis (DKA), or sepsis. The authors evaluated patients under 21 years of age visiting five pediatric emergency departments (EDs) with a study condition. Case patients included had a preceding ED visit within 7 days of diagnosis and underwent case review to confirm a missed diagnosis. The authors compared complication rates and utilization between case and control patients after adjusting for age, sex, and insurance. They analyzed 29,398 children with appendicitis, 5366 with DKA, and 3622 with sepsis, of whom 429, 33, and 46, respectively, had a missed diagnosis. Patients with a missed appendicitis or DKA diagnosis had more hospital days and readmissions, but there were no significant differences for those with sepsis. Those with missed appendicitis were more likely to have abdominal abscess drainage or perforated appendicitis. Those with missed DKA were more likely to have cerebral edema, mechanical ventilation, or death. Those with missed sepsis were less likely to have mechanical ventilation.
AHRQ-funded; HS026503.
Citation: Michelson KA, Bachur RG, Grubenhoff JA .
Outcomes of missed diagnosis of pediatric appendicitis, new-onset diabetic ketoacidosis, and sepsis in five pediatric hospitals.
J Emerg Med 2023 Jul; 65(1):e9-e18. doi: 10.1016/j.jemermed.2023.04.006..
Keywords: Children/Adolescents, Sepsis, Diabetes, Diagnostic Safety and Quality